Home // Gear Tests // Fishing

Scott S4 904-4

Dan Nelson October 2012

What It Is

A fast-action rod with a stiff butt and mid-spine, and soft taper through the tip. Designed as a big water specialist for throwing big dry patterns on heavy leaders, or small nymphing rigs with long, fine leaders.

Retail Price: $745

83

About The Gear Institue Rating
  • 95-100 Extremely high recommendation.
  • 90-94 Enthusiastically recommended. Exceptional.
  • 80-89 Highly recommended - few reservations.
  • 70-79 Recommended. Standard performance.
  • 60-69 Fair. Recommended for certain uses.
  • 50-59 Poor. Not recommended in general.
Click the rating number for detailed information.

The Good

The Bad

The Verdict

  • Great performance casting heavy flies or complex multi-fly rigs
  • Powerful enough to cast in 10-20 mph winds
  • Well suited to drift-boat fishing on big western rivers
  • Great accuracy at middle distances
  • Slightly heavier than most of the other rods in the class
  • Accuracy drops off at longer casting distances
  • Not as versatile as some others

Think big flies on big water. We found the Scott S4 felt most at home fishing wide rivers from a drift boat or while wading, tossing big dry flies to rising trout, dragging big, weighted nymphs through the depths for bottom-feeding fish, or slinging multi-fly rigs when the fish can’t make up their minds. It’s less ideal, though, when going delicate with small dries or tiny nymphs.

Scott S4 904-4

Made in Colorado, the Scott S4 series lives up to its Rocky Mountain heritage. When used on big western rivers like the Missouri, the Big Horn, or the lower Madison where big trout feast on big flies, the S4 kicks butt.

Casting Distance and Accuracy
The S4 sports a unique taper that lets you accurately cast heavy flies while dropping them softly on the surface, but that also lets you feel the gentle tug of a fish on the bottom slurping up big stonefly nymphs. Most of the testers felt accuracy dropped off after casting 30-35 feet and even the best casters amongst us felt accuracy was an issue over 45 feet in windless conditions.

General fit, finish and feel
The California buckeye burl reel seat and deep blue-black rod finish make this is sharp, yet not flashy, rod. The deep butt-end well on the reverse half-well grip allows for a firm handhold – the base of your palm naturally nestles into that deeper-than-normal depression. That helps you better chuck those big bugs.  

Versatility
The stiff butt and mid-section of the rod really boast the power of the cast, while a softer tip provides good sensitivity once you get the fly on the water. You’ll feel every nibble and bump. That means it’s ideal for both deep nymph work, and soft surface feeding. Unfortunately, we found the rod a touch too powerful for delicate presentation of small dries, though is a master with the big flies (wet or dry).

How We Tested It

Fishing for rainbow trout on the Yakima River, Washington, and the Crooked River of Central Oregon. Casting for (and catching) big rainbows from a drift boat on Idaho’s Henry’s Fork and Washington Methow. Beach fishing for Sea Run Cutthroat (SRCs) trout throughout Puget Sound.  Visited eastern Idaho and fished the Teton River and world-famous Henry’s Fork to catch big rainbows and cutthroat trout. Testers included myself, Jim Nelson of the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife, and Donna Meshke.

Behind our ratings:

Value: Price of this rod compared with others designed to perform the same basic function.

Weight: Weight of this rod compared with others designed to perform the same basic function.

Fit in Hand/Grip: Feel of this rod in hand, comfort of holding and casting all day.

Casting Distance: Weight of this rod compared with others designed to perform the same basic function.

Casting Accuracy: Ability to make accurate casts compared with others in the same class and category

Versatility: Usefulness of the rod in a range of situations and angling styles, including dry fly fishing, nymphing, swinging streamers, etc.

The products featured in this test have been loaned to the Gear Institute. For more on our policies regarding editorial objectivity and sample returns, see here.

 

About the Author

Dan Nelson

Dan Nelson

Dan Nelson is a veteran outdoor journalist, and tests sleeping bags and fly fishing rods and reels for the Gear Institute. He's based in the Pacific Northwest.

Ready to Purchase?

Retailer

Product Name

Price

Telluride AnglerScott S4 904-4 $745.00
* When you use links above to make your purchase, a portion of the sale helps support Gear Institute.

Ratings

Weight

6
10

Fit in Hand / Grip

8
10

Casting Distance

8
10

Casting Accuracy

6
10

Versatility

7
10

Value

  8
10

Gear Institute Rating (Total Score)

  83
100

Weight

2.75 oz

Related Tests

Twitter Feed