Gear Institute Expert Test Menu

Simms Headwaters Large Sling Pack

- published Saturday, 15 August 2015

86

2015

RATINGS

Organization
8
Comfort
9
Adjustability
8
Ventilation
7
Water-resistance
7
Capacity
9
GEAR INSTITUTE RATING
86

SHOP

MSRP
LOW PRICE
$120.00
N/A
Support Gear Institute. If you make a purchase after clicking on the links above, a portion of the sale helps support this site.

THE GOOD

  • Generous capacity easily fits three large fly boxes
  • Wide waist support creates all-day comfort
  • Lots of compartments keep you organized
  • Convenient, well-designed tippet holder

THE BAD

  • The zippers bind up if you overstuff the pack
  • No dedicated water bottle holder
  • No effective way to secure a long-handled guide net

THE VERDICT

Professional guides might find this sling to be a bit small. But for everyone else, this pack offers generous storage capacity—and keeps it from feeling unwieldy.

FULL REVIEW

Organization
This is far from a pocketless sack. Whereas some slings minimize the number of compartments for a more streamlined carry, the Large Headwaters is divided into three zippered sections, each with additional pouches inside. The smallest of those is a hard-sized case for a fly box. Some testers don’t love hard-sided compartments because they’re less forgiving about the box you can shove inside. If your box happens to fit, great! But the hard-sided design doesn’t accommodate a too-big fly box. The tippet-holder, however, is one of the best we’ve used. It’s simply an elastic cord and cordlock sewn to a Velcro patch that sticks to the hard-sided compartment. But its placement is perfect—front and center once you swing the pack around to your front—and the design makes it easy to switch out spools. 

Comfort
This pack is “Cadillac” plush. A thick (3/4”?) slab of egg-crate foam cushions your back from whatever you’re carrying and improves ventilation (see below). The wide, rigid shoulder and hip straps ably support heavy loads, and the design nestles securely into the curves of your back. One professional guide stuffed it with three liters of water and a full complement of gear and found it comfortable after a full day of wear. 

Adjustability
Although it’s obviously designed for “Mr. Medium,” this sling does adapt to shorter (to perhaps 5’3”) and taller anglers. The waist strap accommodates large (but not XXXL) waistlines.

Ventilation
Its large size means there’s a lot of pack clinging to your body, but Simms does an impressive job of mitigating heat buildup. The main compartment is lined with egg-crate foam and mesh fabric that lets some air circulate between the pack and your back, and the shoulder and hip straps use a honeycomb mesh that’s only mildly sweat-trapping.

Water-resistance
The 420-denier fabric is coated with a DWR treatment, so it repels drizzle and brief showers. But it’s not waterproof, and wading more than waist-deep will soak the contents.

Capacity
With this pack, there’s always room for one more—one more jacket, one more fly box, or one more sandwich. It holds a lot (15 liters, according to Simms) but it’s still a tad small for professional guides. Self-guided anglers should find its storage more than sufficient, and may appreciate generous storage that still manages to feel streamlined.

How We Tested It

The packs in this test were used by a team of fly-fishermen (and women) on multiple trips on Rocky Mountain rivers and lakes.

The products featured in this test have been loaned to the Gear Institute. For more on our policies regarding editorial objectivity and sample returns, see here.

About the Author

Kelly Bastone

Kelly Bastone

For writer and outdoorswoman Kelly Bastone, gear-testing is just part of the daily routine: Her home in Steamboat Springs, Colorado puts world-class skiing, mountain biking, and fly-fishing right outside her door. Read her work at kellybastone.com


Comments

comments powered by Disqus
MSRP
LOW PRICE
$120.00
N/A
Support Gear Institute. If you make a purchase after clicking on the links above, a portion of the sale helps support this site.

RATINGS

Organization
8
Comfort
9
Adjustability
8
Ventilation
7
Water-resistance
7
Capacity
9
GEAR INSTITUTE RATING
86

Specs

  • Unisex

Jump To