Gear Institute Expert Test Menu

Rugged Creek Traditional 4-wt

- published June 2015

77

2015

RATINGS

Weight
6
Fit in Hand/Grip
6
Casting Distance
5
Casting Accuracy
6
Fish-on action/hook-set
7
Versatility
7
GEAR INSTITUTE RATING
77

SHOP

MSRP
LOW PRICE
$220.00
N/A
Support Gear Institute. If you make a purchase after clicking on the links above, a portion of the sale helps support this site.

THE GOOD

  • Least expensive rod in the test
  • Good general purpose design
  • Comes standard with reel-mount rod tube

THE BAD

  • Heavy swing-weight
  • Lack of accuracy
  • Poor casting power

THE VERDICT

The Rugged Creek Traditional rod offers a medium-fast action with a soft-flex tip that proved to be relatively easy to cast. Unfortunately, the Traditional lacks the power of a true fast-action (like the Scott Radian or Orvis Recon) and the accuracy of a medium-action like the Sage Accel. But the easy-casting nature of the Rugged Creek is ideally suited for novices who are still perfecting their casting stroke. 

FULL REVIEW

The Rugged Creek Traditional rod series addresses a growing need in fly fishing—affordable rods with decent performance for novices and occasional anglers. The Traditional series offers much better performance than most of the other rods in its price range. 

Fit and feel
The Rugged Creek Traditional sports a cigar-grip that felt a bit narrow for me (though testers with smaller hands really liked the grip). We all felt the rod was a bit butt-heavy when mounted with a medium- or large-arbor reel like the Sage 2230 or Orvis Access. A full day of casting from a Deschutes River drift boat produced a bit of hand strain, suggesting we had to over-grip the slightly unbalanced rod.

Distance and Accuracy
The soft-flex tip of the Rugged Creek rod helped lay down soft presentations of dry flies, but negatively affected casting accuracy. The tip lacked the radial stiffness to keep the fly aligned with a target. The core of the rod, on the other hand, offered good stiffness for power and line speed, but again, that soft tip affected overall distance performance. That soft tip sapped a bit of line speed at the end of a cast.

General performance
The soft tip did offer good sensitivity on strikes, and the rod’s butt section had the strength to control good-sized trout. I struggled at times with multi-fly rigs, both in casting and in hook-setting, largely because of the soft tip, but with a bit of effort we caught fish on dries, nymphs and streamers, so the Rugged Creek proved itself somewhat versatile.

The Traditional is also available in 4-wt through 8-wt versions in 9-ft lengths.

How We Tested It

The rods in this test were used while fishing an assortment of trout streams, rivers, and lakes in Washington, Oregon, Idaho and Montana. Our test team also included a retired Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife Game Warden, two experienced female anglers, and—on occasion—a professional fishing guide. We fished each rod with dry flies, nymphs, and dry/dropper rigs, as well as the occasional streamer.

The products featured in this test have been loaned to the Gear Institute. For more on our policies regarding editorial objectivity and sample returns, see here.

About the Author

Dan Nelson

Dan Nelson

Dan Nelson is the fly fishing editor of Gear Institute.com. He is a veteran outdoor journalist based in the Pacific Northwest. Follow him at Google+.


Comments

comments powered by Disqus
MSRP
LOW PRICE
$220.00
N/A
Support Gear Institute. If you make a purchase after clicking on the links above, a portion of the sale helps support this site.

RATINGS

Weight
6
Fit in Hand/Grip
6
Casting Distance
5
Casting Accuracy
6
Fish-on action/hook-set
7
Versatility
7
GEAR INSTITUTE RATING
77

Weight

3.5 oz

Jump To