Gear Institute Expert Test Menu

L.L. Bean West Branch Wading Boot Review

- published June 2017

79

2017

RATINGS

Fit
4
Traction
10
Support
6
Weight
5
Features
6
Durability
8
GEAR INSTITUTE RATING
79

SHOP

MSRP
LOW PRICE
$149.00
N/A
Support Gear Institute. If you make a purchase after clicking on the links above, a portion of the sale helps support this site.

THE GOOD

  • High cuff fits long-legged anglers
  • Studs deliver excellent traction
  • Tough construction
  • Good value for a studded boot

THE BAD

  • Heavy
  • Sloppy, built on a men’s last
  • No hook for gravel guards

THE VERDICT

The women’s West Branch Wading Boot, Studded from L.L. Bean is one of the least-expensive ways to enjoy the sticky, rock-gripping traction provided by a studded sole. But it’s not a women’s-specific chassis—it’s a men’s boot offered in smaller sizes—and the high-volume fit is too loose to provide solid support.

FULL REVIEW

Fit
The ankle cuff is higher than any other boot in this test. That’s a boon for taller, long-legged anglers who can appreciate the extra support. But on shorter testers (I’m 5’0”) it rubbed against my lower calf. And the footbox is enormous: High and wide, it provided too much volume for even my C-width feet, which slipped and sloshed around inside. Most anglers will want to double up on heavyweight socks, or use the West Branch for cold-weather fishing, when they’ll be wearing an additional neoprene sock within their waders’ booties.

Traction
Many sticky-bottomed boots accommodate studs, which must be purchased separately, and installed by the user. But the West Branch comes with studs included, making these boots a very good value. Those steel micro-spikes, along with the AquaStealth rubber, provide for very good grip, even on slimy rocks. The traction was among the best in test.

Support
The broad sole should deliver good stability. Instead, the high-volume fit undercuts the boot’s support. The stiff upper limits how tightly you can pull the laces, so even when the laces were cinched as tightly as possible, the interior never closed securely around my foot. With my foot sliding around inside, I never enjoyed the kind of stability I hope to have in fast-moving water. I felt off-balance when climbing hills and stepping over rounded rocks.

Weight
The metal studs, thick rubber sole, and beefy leather uppers combine to make this a rather heavy boot. Dry or wet, it was the weightiest in this test, which was most noticeable when hiking to and from the water.

Features
Most boots in this price range don’t include studs, but the West Branch boot does. It also features drainage ports. No toe hook for securing gravel guards.

Durability
The toe is reinforced with a thick band of rubber, and the stitched sole promises better longevity than glued constructions.

How We Tested It

The boots in this test were used while wade-fishing across the Rockies, from northern New Mexico to southern Idaho to my backyard trout stream, the Yampa River in Colorado. Conditions included algae-cloaked rocks, gravel, sand, muck, and dryland hiking up to 4 miles on access trails.

For more reviews beyond this 2017 test, check out our Fly Rod tests, Fly Fishing Pack tests, and other related fishing gear tests

The products featured in this test have been loaned to the Gear Institute. For more on our policies regarding editorial objectivity and sample returns, see here.

About the Author

Kelly Bastone

Kelly Bastone

For writer and outdoorswoman Kelly Bastone, gear-testing is just part of the daily routine: Her home in Steamboat Springs, Colorado puts world-class skiing, mountain biking, and fly-fishing right outside her door. Read her work at kellybastone.com


Comments

comments powered by Disqus
MSRP
LOW PRICE
$149.00
N/A
Support Gear Institute. If you make a purchase after clicking on the links above, a portion of the sale helps support this site.

RATINGS

Fit
4
Traction
10
Support
6
Weight
5
Features
6
Durability
8
GEAR INSTITUTE RATING
79

Specs

  • Gender: Women's

Weight

3 lbs. 1 oz.

Jump To